WTB Working Alternator for m54

Engine, Transmission, Final Drive, and anything in between belongs here.
Post Reply
BJerolimic
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 2:24 pm
Location: Montville, NJ . . . . . . '98 M3 - '01 M5 - '08 X5

WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by BJerolimic »

Wife's e39's alternator is failing. It had a bunch of leaves packed in the back and the air ducting to the alt, I cleaned it out and it worked again for a month or two but now the red light is on again. I haven't checked the car yet (she is at her moms currently) but I'm guessing I'll need to throw in a working alternator so let me know what you have available. Thanks!
Image

and gone but not forgotten:
'00 323Ci Steel Grey / Black Dinan & UUC & Schnitzer mods
'89 325iX Diamond Black / Black 4dr 5spd Dinan chip, Ireland exhaust, H&R+Koni
'01 525iTa

edw1
Posts: 697
Joined: Fri Sep 17, 2004 10:59 am
Location: Morris County
Contact:

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by edw1 »

The last time I looked, there are four different alternators used on the M54: Bosch/Valeo and low current/high current. They are not interchangeable.
ImageImage

BJerolimic
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 2:24 pm
Location: Montville, NJ . . . . . . '98 M3 - '01 M5 - '08 X5

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by BJerolimic »

edw1 wrote:The last time I looked, there are four different alternators used on the M54: Bosch/Valeo and low current/high current. They are not interchangeable.
just got back from wrecker in Whippany where I learned the same thing... some have different shaped pluggs too. I need a 120 amp Valeo with rectangular plug
Image

and gone but not forgotten:
'00 323Ci Steel Grey / Black Dinan & UUC & Schnitzer mods
'89 325iX Diamond Black / Black 4dr 5spd Dinan chip, Ireland exhaust, H&R+Koni
'01 525iTa

colin
Posts: 619
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2005 5:09 pm

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by colin »

I found a video that can help fix your problem.

http://youtu.be/7cG97osQ560

Best part is that this works with any kind of alternator, and you don't have to buy anything.

edw1
Posts: 697
Joined: Fri Sep 17, 2004 10:59 am
Location: Morris County
Contact:

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by edw1 »

Try Autozone or some other parts chain for rebuilds of questionable quality.




Image
ImageImage

BJerolimic
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 2:24 pm
Location: Montville, NJ . . . . . . '98 M3 - '01 M5 - '08 X5

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by BJerolimic »

edw1 wrote:Try Autozone or some other parts chain for rebuilds of questionable quality.
indeed I have been trying to avoid that temptation


do you think a rebuild from a local place like J&C Starters & Alternators in Chatham would be better?

https://plus.google.com/102657238912028 ... l=us&hl=en
Image

and gone but not forgotten:
'00 323Ci Steel Grey / Black Dinan & UUC & Schnitzer mods
'89 325iX Diamond Black / Black 4dr 5spd Dinan chip, Ireland exhaust, H&R+Koni
'01 525iTa

RonG
Posts: 214
Joined: Thu May 20, 2010 7:27 pm

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by RonG »

IIRC as long as the output capacity and connectors are a match, you can go with either supplier. Don't know if you've checked already but BavAuto carries the 120A Bosch unit (rectangular plug) for $203 after return of your core. The Valeo does not come up for an '01 525iT and they are usually right about what fits.

If you get rebuild quotes for much over $100 but the vendor doesn't give you that warm and fuzzy feeling, the peace of mind might be worth the extra coin.
2011 Azurite Black/Oyster Individual 335xi
2003 Black Sapphire/Natural Brown 330Ci

edw1
Posts: 697
Joined: Fri Sep 17, 2004 10:59 am
Location: Morris County
Contact:

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by edw1 »

My E46 shows only Bosch on Realoem.com but I have a Valeo. I think the correct alternators went in the trash next to limited slip diff internals.
ImageImage

BJerolimic
Posts: 740
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 2:24 pm
Location: Montville, NJ . . . . . . '98 M3 - '01 M5 - '08 X5

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by BJerolimic »

RonG wrote:IIRC as long as the output capacity and connectors are a match, you can go with either supplier. Don't know if you've checked already but BavAuto carries the 120A Bosch unit (rectangular plug) for $203 after return of your core. The Valeo does not come up for an '01 525iT and they are usually right about what fits.

If you get rebuild quotes for much over $100 but the vendor doesn't give you that warm and fuzzy feeling, the peace of mind might be worth the extra coin.

from searching the interwebs it seems the Bosch uses a different pulley than the Valeo, and the rebuilds don't come with a pulley and I couldn't use my Valeo pulley on the Bosh alternator. Also the Bosch supposedly uses a different sized lower mounting bolt and with a nut to secure it (or maybe the guy had to use a nut due to the different sized bolt)

the BavAuto and other online vendors all seem priced around the same of the autozone/pep boys rebuilds and I'm guessing they are similar 'chinese' rebuilds?
Image

and gone but not forgotten:
'00 323Ci Steel Grey / Black Dinan & UUC & Schnitzer mods
'89 325iX Diamond Black / Black 4dr 5spd Dinan chip, Ireland exhaust, H&R+Koni
'01 525iTa

colin
Posts: 619
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2005 5:09 pm

Re: WTB Working Alternator for m54

Post by colin »

So, all kidding aside: I'm on my 3rd alternator in my M54 325Ci. The first BMW one lasted five years and about 75,000 miles. The 2nd BMW one (with a massive one-year warranty!) lasted three years and 50,000 miles.

Six years and 80,000 miles later, I'm still happily using my AutoZone Valeo alternator with its lifetime warranty. And you guys know I don't exactly baby my car.

Your mileage may vary.

Post Reply